96.2% would refer friends and family to us

5 stars Verified customer

Excellent attention to detail in solving all your automotive needs! Chris Timpano is the greatest mechanic!

5 stars Verified customer

Both myself and my car are treated with care and kindness here. In addition to normal maintenance an oil changes, any other concerns are always addressed. From tires to transmissions. Thank you!

5 stars Customer since 2014

everything great with service friendly and helpful staff I was just a bit surprised that about 2 weeks ago I bought 2 tires from you and I had a nail in the tire and was charge to fix the hole just thought as good customer service you would just do that for free

4 stars Verified customer

Delivered as promised

5 stars Verified customer

Friendly & knowledgeable staff, always willing to help and advise.

5 stars Verified customer

I've used the Flemington American Tire and Auto 3 or 4 times since we moved to the area a few years ago. I've had an excellent experience every single time. Courteous desk staff, knowledgeable about their products and services. It's usually easy to get a time for service that works with my schedule, and parts/tires are available quickly. Pricing is reasonable. I'd guess there are cheaper places, but I don't feel like it's worth the hassle personally as I trust these guys, and that's rare for an auto place based on my past experience.

5 stars Verified customer

As usual, efficient, professional, & reasonable

2 stars Customer since 2013

Not very happy. I asked for my car back by 11 and at 11:30 when I called for my car they had not started working on it, making me late for Lacrosse. I asked for an oil change, to check belts that were squeaking, and to fix an aux cord function. The Belts still squeak and the aux cord still doesn't work. If they had started my car earlier to have it done by 11 maybe they actually could have looked at the belts and figured out which one was the problem or at least called me to tell me they cant fix the aux cord. At a place where my family and my self have always taken our cars I felt like a 3rd class citizen and that my services where strictly monetary in value.

American Tire & Auto Care - Flemington replied:

We are sorry we didn't meeting your time schedule. Please give us your info and we will look into this unfortunate situation. Your time is important - we are sorry.

5 stars Verified customer

American Tire always services my car quickly and never overcharges or charges for work that is not necessary.

5 stars Verified customer

Excellent shop and service finally a professional shop that will complete work the right way and on time.